-
Featured
- #481
just seeing this and i have a question about your post...Sorry, this is misleading. You can hook directly to the battery; it will not make any difference on the computers ability to monitor "battery health" which is what this statement is all about. Here's why:
*The BMS gets its information from the current sensor, also known as the Hall effect device, which is a device that measures a field around a wire to determine how much current is flowing and the direction it is flowing. (charging or discharging) It is essentially the heart of the monitoring system for the electrical charging system health. It can determine if the charge system has a fault based on how much current is drawn during operation. (With ignition on and running)
*If you have a 6.7, you have two batteries, (Or dual battery option in gasser) both batteries using Black/Violet wires to ground, ~1/0 gauge. Both are attached directly to the chassis/engine, and one smaller lead ~10 gauge, parallel on the passenger side battery, running through a Hall Effect device to monitor current draw or charge current, during operation. (Engine running) The two larger wires represent a shunt; the smaller wire is the measurement plane for the current sensor. also connected to the chassis in parallel with the two larger wires in parallel. (See schematic for visual) Heavy current flows through the large wires, a small current flows through the small wire in parallel, most likely "calibrated" to some extent to determine the current flow of the system.
*Heavy current devices are connected directly to the battery such as a winch, and perhaps some accessories like a plow, not to the chassis. They are not monitored by the current sensor.
*If your truck is not running, you can still use the battery functions like a winch, PTO, lights, etc., and the computer is not in play.
*Hooking up a high current accessory draws its current through additional wire in series if hooking up through the chassis to battery connection, essentially dropping voltage in the wires, thereby reducing the voltage at the device. (The wires essentially become resistors at high current draw.)
To avoid this occurrence, a device such as a winch is directly connected to the battery. (Here's a video of A-Rod installing a winch in a 23 YM, the wires are directly connected to the battery.(Skip to 51:00 minutes to see hook-up) There is no ill effect of hooking directly to the battery.
Ok, so reading the manual is always a good thing. But understanding what and why it is printed, is also essential. So why does the manual make this statement? The batteries and charge system are monitored for health over time and as maintenance to determine charge/discharge. As batteries age, they may suffer with less capacity. The computer can possibly tell when the batteries are deteriorating via the sensor (hall effect device) and determine if a battery needs to be replaced or malfunctioning. It assumes that if you draw directly from the battery, the BMS cannot determine if there is an issue with the charging system.
By the way, as a side note, there is a lot of evidence that this does not work so well. How many people have had two batteries in parallel, getting error codes, just to find out one of the batteries were low or dead when measured independently.
If the BMS does not know how much current is drawn it can't determine the health of the batteries. (Supposedly) The fact is, you can draw all kinds of current with the ignition off, start the truck, and it will replenish, and the computer won't care. But if you kill the battery, all bets are off as to what it will do.
If you add up all of the accessory current capabilities of the upfitter switches, it's a whopping 180A+ capacity. Not to mention you can add a relay and draw even more. In this case, there is no difference if you hook accessory grounds to the chassis or the battery, it is still going to draw current from both batteries and the alternator (s) will supply the necessary current required for high demands via the regulators.
The second part of the paragraph is also telling, In quotes:
"Note: If you add electrical accessories or components to your vehicle, this may adversely affect battery performance, durability, and the performance of other electrical systems on your vehicle."
Yes. Absolutely true. If the battery is drawn down, the BMS won't work right, you can cause irreparable damage to the batteries, the loss of voltage can cause the tranny to "relearn", etc. May even throw a code. But this is not the fault of the common or chassis ground, it is a fault of the battery going dead due to inability to keep up with the demand. If you run a winch and kill your battery, you will have the same issue. And the statement is assuming the BMS will read and prevent this.
Not if the engine isn't running. And certainly not in the case where a winch is in operation.
The statement is really misleading. It's all about the battery monitoring system. I really wish tech writers could clarify this stuff. You notice they don't mention the winch.
Here's a schematic of the current sensor with a single battery and the schematic of our trucks to the right. Note the difference in the ground and chassis ground connections. The chassis ground is terminated at the engine with the common ground through two large wires. Essentially the same electrical point. It will make little or no difference whether the device is hooked up to the chassis or the battery post.
View attachment 202149
Hope I didn't miss anything. It's late...![]()
On my 2022 (single battery) there is a current transformer-looking device NOT the device in A-rod's video. If I have a completely stock wiring setup and i wire my winch to the chassis for ground and then wire the hot to the positive post then the flow will be measured by the device because all wires connected to the negative go through said device. This makes sense, not questions here
However,
If i wire the negative from the winch directly to the battery post and DONT run it through said device... you're saying that is the same as the chassis ground and it'll still be measured by the device?
Could you walk me through how thats possible?

