Trying to decide whether I want this hidden 12K winch setup with 90 feet of line, or a replacement Steelcraft bumper with a Sherpa 17K winch and 150 feet of line.
What is the intended purpose/use you will be seeing solely with the winch? Is it more for functionality? Looks? Do you go off-road where you need it for self recoveries or is it more to help others in need? Move trees/debris off trails in a controlled manner?
Now as far as the bumper. Is that more for functionality or looks? I understand even if purchased for looks, functionality/protection comes with it. Is hitting wildlife on the road a great concern where you are?
I know ccw had a great post a while ago of why he chooses not to have an aftermarket bumper, I do believe you were involved in that discussion.
For me, the decision to stick with the “stock” look was easy. Although deer are prevalent in my area, it is not highly likely I will hit one, I have not seen an aftermarket bumper I liked the look of (my opinion), this Superduty is the largest/tallest passenger vehicle I’ve owned. I keep my mileage relatively low as it’s mostly an evening/weekend truck. I do think that just adding the winch itself adds some protection/ rigidity to the frame/front end. But maybe I’m wrong and a front end collision would end up damaging more on my vehicle.
Things that would have possibly changed my mind were as follows,
Everyday driver with lots for highway
Previously hit wildlife/very high chance of hitting wildlife
Been in a collision where the front bumper would have saved lives and not taken them.
If I spent more time off road then I do (would look like a brodozzer with all the pavement time this truck gets)
Anyways, that was my train of thought for why I chose what I chose. No doubt the new bumper and larger winch will be that much more capable then my truck, but at what cost.