The reason this reductive nihilism is so prevalent is that we've become a society of the professionally ignorant. The more people who care, who choose to draw a distinction between themselves and a digital veal calf, the more impact the refusal will have. As we're always told, the resistance of one person never did anything...
... But the informed resistance of Millions would.
Our collective apathy is absolutely the fault of the impotent 'nothing matters' argument of civic weakness, fostered by a lifetime of exposure to an increasingly paternalistic system of social controls. The American citizen has become an industrially farmed animal wherein the data we produce - enabled by our absolutely subsidized device fixation - is collected, analyzed, aggregated, packaged, sold, deanonymized, analyzed again and again for various interests and behavioral focusing, contextualized, repackaged, resold - ad nauseam.
The real-world value of the data we produce is easily in the range of Trillions of dollars, annually, yet not only do we give it away for free, we continue to pay for products and services that collect these streams of data. Facebook and Google are entirely funded by the monetization of your digital production. The perfect and inescapable threat inherent in converting the modern social constituency into an oligarchy of corporate interests while reducing the human animal to a digital agricultural chattel hybrid is inarguable. In an era where people's real wages haven't increased in decades, and inflation is out of control, why is the product of an individual's production the right of a disinterests and often hostile corporate interest? That our legislators are too uneducated and, well, corrupt, is the only thing that prevents comprehensive digital identity and privacy controls. All we have to do is require our representatives to address the issue, but we don't. We only talk about the salacious issues the media and political operatives have cooked up for us - day in and day out...
The fact is, we've become a fat, drugged, lazy, bitchy, passive, domesticated population dependent on our various supply chains and entitlements. It's inescapable because we talk big and act small.
I worked in domestic surveillance and artificial intelligence for almost ten years. I left sometime during the Obama regime. What we were doing then, and who was providing the funding - and why - became an issue of principle for me. Right now, more than ever, the remaining citizens and heirs of the western tradition need to internalize that our digital dragnet is the end of the modern world as we understand it and advocate accordingly. Here, there; wherever the topic is raised.
There is no Republican versus Democrat dichotomy. Right now there is one party, represented across a narrow spectrum of socially inflammatory topics designed to offer the illusion of choice. The two dominant parties have inarguably transitioned into two new, very loaded, unpopular designations. The Left now represents a wildly incompatible series of positions that are nothing short of Communist. The right has changed as well, since the formal neocon consolidation of power in 1994, the party has only one unified position, known as zionism.
The fact is, the platform of the left seeks nothing but the dissolution of the western state, and the right seeks only to serve their monied interest, and above all else, the interests of a foreign power who we have already and freely given 14.7 Trillion dollars to since 1949. Bear in mind our current national debt of 28.5 Trillion dollars.
Realize that for several years now, it has not been the civil governing structure in control of our mindlessly connected societies, it is the cloistered, activist, indoctrinated, boards and committees of dozens of companies like Facebook, Google, Fox, Disney, et al. Private corporations dictate the nature of the Overton window and restrict all dissent under the guise of catchwords and scary accusations.
All of this, literally 100% of it, is a consequence of our collective unwillingness to demand ownership of our personal meta-data production and explicit content controls. So the nihilist is right, one person, doing one thing, does nothing.
Never has.
That's why getting in front of these bullshit arguments whenever they are vomited on screen is so critical. It's not that there is an expectation that minds will be changed, or words believed, it's that they poison the threads they're injected into and these types of threads are important. That someone doesn't see the point is fuck all irrelevant... Go away. Start a privacy suck thread, don't co-opt a thread of people who WANT to take whatever ineffectual steps they can - because these are the people that perceive the threat and feel compelled to resist. These are the people who do the thinking that others later copy.
These are valuable walkthroughs, there is literally no value created or conferred by dropping in solely to shit on them.