Edit: the "double-nickel limit" goes back to a Federal Law from 1973 passed after the Arab Oil Embargo. 55 mph is the most efficient speed for most vehicles (not Zamboni's, obviously), balancing the inherent efficiency of internal combustion engines with viscous drag from airflow.
I read your statement about logic, and your logic actually is pretty sound (doing 55 while towing is good, and you can go a little faster un-loaded). It is based on a concept similar to terminal velocity. The speed at which you fall is an equilibrium between two forces:
F-
g - gravity's pull on your crazy self (who the F^*$ jumps out of a perfectly good airplane?) and
F-
Drag - the drag cause by moving you through the atmosphere.
Good Video:
For a vehicle driving down the highway (falling horizontally?), we balance energy transfer from the engine to the wheels to maintain speed and push the truck through the air. After ~55mph we see diminishing returns on fuel economy, and we are limited by engine efficiency and drag coefficients (*math happens*).
Increasing your speed above 55mph causes you to burn more fuel due to the air drag force overtaking your trucks ability to efficiently propel you forward.
Fun reference:
As truck fleets and policy makers aim to curb big rig fuel consumption, the secret weapon is driver behavior.
www.nationalgeographic.com