Time for new Goodyear tires need opinions

Aggressive "looking" tires mean nothing on the ice/snowpacked road.

I bet the 3PSR tires have more siping. because that's where you winter traction comes from. Not the size or spacing or visual aggressiveness of the lugs themselves. it's the siping that matters. That's why M/Ts are terrible in winter. UNLESS you find a tire shop that will sipe them the old fashioned way.
 
I had the OEM Duratracs and ripped the sidewall on a rock on a gravel road. Very disappointing to say the least. I now have the 3 ply sidewall Duratracs and they’ve held up well (30k miles). But I want a change and I’m looking hard at the Mickey Thompson Baja Boss AT for my next set of tires. They’re rated for snow and ice as well, which I need in the Durango, CO area. I’ve had Nitto ATs years ago. Decent but nothing remarkable. BFGs on other trucks. Liked them. Didn’t love them. And the siping is inadequate for where I am now. I do not want to run another set of Duratracs. Not a hater. I just think I can get tires I like more.
 
I have a set and purchased them with the same discount. I need a tire really good on snow and ice and the original Duratrac always did me good. I bought these just before last winter but since we really didn't have much of a winter I can't say they were awesome just because I didn't have much time on bad roads. No complaints with the tire so far though. My wife has Toyo AT3's on her 4Runner and the only thing I can say about those is they seem to be wearing quickly so already planning on not buying that tire when they completely wear out. Good luck.
 
Every excellent winter tire has every single treadblock/ridge/tread pattern feature fully and utterly "micro-"siped. And even then, their bite on ice only lasts, or, is at it's peak performance the first winter (because the folks who run these tires swap to summer tires between April and October, or between June and September if you're Finnish.

/give or take

The slightly higher-priced Duratrac called the Duratrac R/T, may have a few more microsipes in it. I does not appear to weigh much more than the 60 or 61 lb OG Duratrac that comes on our Tremors. That's one reason they sidewall puncture easily; they're built to be very light in weight.

My next set of five tires will be a 37 X 11.5 X 18 and if no one else produces a decent tire in that size then I'll run that gawddamned Ridge Grappler. Can't believe I'm saying that.

I'd love to see the Falken AT4W in a 37 X 11.5; at the very least a Toyo A/TIII.

Come on, man!
 
I am replacing my original tires on Friday with BFG KO3’s. Have about 28000 on original tires and would never purchase Goodyear for any reason or cost. They are in my opinion an inferior tire. Have usually replaced Goodyear tires on every vehicle I have owned with them usually within 3000-4000 miles. Always replaced them with BFG or Nitto.
 
Goodyear duratracs were made at the Fayetteville Nc plant 10 years ago when I had them as a client. Not sure if they still are but Goodyear announced that plant will close in a year or so. The quality level in a closing plant or in a plant dialing in how to run a transferred product is a concern.
 
Opinions are like assholes obviously, but you couldn't donate a set of Duratracs to me. They've let me down every opportunity. I'd be looking at Toyo ATIII, BFG HD, or Falkens as others have mentioned.

Even my Nitto Terra Grappler G3's are great in dry weather and moderate rain, but they were horrible in snow and ice compared to Toyo ATIII. So YMMV, but shop around even with the discount I'd spend more on something other than GoodYear.
 
Aggressive "looking" tires mean nothing on the ice/snowpacked road.

I bet the 3PSR tires have more siping. because that's where you winter traction comes from. Not the size or spacing or visual aggressiveness of the lugs themselves. it's the siping that matters. That's why M/Ts are terrible in winter. UNLESS you find a tire shop that will sipe them the old fashioned way.
Understood. The RTs do have more siping than the original Duratrac but the snow rating isn't the best compared to some other "snow rated" tires. The RT is rated as 3P but I'll leave the reviews on that aspect to those that live in that environment.
 
I've lived in, and traveled extensively through the California Sierra's for many years. My biggest safety exposure is always winter ice and snow driving...especially ice. I've tried most every major brand AT and hybrid MS/MT tire out there.

The original 2009 versions of GY 3peak Duratrac's (before they changed their rubber composition to achieve longer mileage) was good on ice... soft pliable rubber and thin flexible sidewall. Not the toughest tires for rocks and sharp object terrain but great in snow.

Today I'm a big fan of the Mickey Thompson Baja Boss ATs. One of the toughest most robust tires out there, yet still fantastic on ice and snow. They perform well in more varied terrains than any other tire I can think of. Also extremely quiet for what it is. Only drawback is their weight and some fuel mileage drop... but in LT305 70R18s they're also wider.
 
I've lived in, and traveled extensively through the California Sierra's for many years. My biggest safety exposure is always winter ice and snow driving...especially ice. I've tried most every major brand AT and hybrid MS/MT tire out there.

The original 2009 versions of GY 3peak Duratrac's (before they changed their rubber composition to achieve longer mileage) was good on ice... soft pliable rubber and thin flexible sidewall. Not the toughest tires for rocks and sharp object terrain but great in snow.

Today I'm a big fan of the Mickey Thompson Baja Boss ATs. One of the toughest most robust tires out there, yet still fantastic on ice and snow. They perform well in more varied terrains than any other tire I can think of. Also extremely quiet for what it is. Only drawback is their weight and some fuel mileage drop... but in LT305 70R18s they're also wider.
I too travel extensively in the Sierra's but generally in the summer months. When I need tires again, I will consider these but may opt to get different wheels than stock, ideally 9". Do you run these with the original wheels?
 
Got 45k out the OEM duratracks. Got the LTs and rotated out the spare...just turned 94k..You can tell the difference between the one OEM and LTs. I will be getting another set of LT before winter.
 
Not sure why so much hate of the Duratrac , i have ran 2 sets of the OEM version and now I'm on a set of Duratrac RT's . I also had a set of Toyo RT's and they are good until worn down half way, they didn't work well for me in the rain at that point. I have close to 10K miles on the new Duratrac RT's and could not be happier. My rotation schedule is 5K
 

Attachments

  • Duratrac RT pic1.webp
    Duratrac RT pic1.webp
    741.6 KB · Views: 31
  • Duratrac RT pic2.webp
    Duratrac RT pic2.webp
    575.1 KB · Views: 28
I too travel extensively in the Sierra's but generally in the summer months. When I need tires again, I will consider these but may opt to get different wheels than stock, ideally 9". Do you run these with the original wheels?
Yes, I put them on the original 18". Honestly, I was expecting the extra width to sorta sit with a bulge on the wheel, but it seems to fit suppressing well... it looks like it belongs. That said, I'm sure wider wheels would no doubt be more appropriate for performance and wear. I really do believe the design of this tire is fantastic. It encompasses the most, and best all around handling of so many variable terrains... especially snow and ice... and so quietly too.
 
The Repulsor! 😬

...and the Venom Power Swampthing! (the only other 37 X 11.5 X R18LT b'sides the damnable Ridge Grappler)


[which is why I've just commited to a 17" wheel/tire setup composed of a 37 X 11.5 X 17 Nitto Recon Grappler wrapped around a Vision Flow 351 size 17 X 8.5" +18mm Super Duty wheel]
 
Last edited:
Got 45k out the OEM duratracks. Got the LTs and rotated out the spare...just turned 94k..You can tell the difference between the one OEM and LTs. I will be getting another set of LT before winter.
You still on stock rims, right?
 
The Repulsor! 😬

...and the Venom Power Swampthing! (the only other 37 X 11.5 X R18LT b'sides the damnable Ridge Grappler)


[which is why I've just commited to a 17" wheel/tire setup composed of a 37 X 11.5 X 17 Nitto Recon Grappler wrapped around a Vision Flow 351 size 17 X 8.5" +18mm Super Duty wheel]
Seen these on a f150 parked at the rec near me. I figure they'd be awesome on my bronco that I putter around town in. Never would put them on my tank of a truck though...

Edit: the ones I saw were way more "aggressive" looking than those 🤔
 
The Repulsor! 😬

...and the Venom Power Swampthing! (the only other 37 X 11.5 X R18LT b'sides the damnable Ridge Grappler)


[which is why I've just commited to a 17" wheel/tire setup composed of a 37 X 11.5 X 17 Nitto Recon Grappler wrapped around a Vision Flow 351 size 17 X 8.5" +18mm Super Duty wheel]
Seen these on a f150 parked at the rec near me. I figure they'd be awesome on my bronco that I putter around town in. Never would put them on my tank of a truck though. I looked again and the ones I saw were the M/T, not the A/T
 
Not sure why so much hate of the Duratrac ,
You must have forgotten the mantra of some: "I want a Tremor because it has unique wheels, tires, shocks, and a lift. First thing I'm doing is changing the shocks and tires because they suck, I don't like the wheels, and I'm putting on a bigger lift. BTW - who makes a locker that fits our front axle?" :ROFLMAO:

Yes, I'm joking. You guys can do whatever you want and I'm all for it! (y) ;)
 
^ ^ ^ true story.

Although I wanted the axle gearing and the wheels. If there were a decent 37 X 11.5 X 18 tire offered (there are two, but two that are each a no-go for me, those being the Ridge Grappler and then the Venom Power Swampthing [seriously?]), then the factory Tremor road wheel would remain forever on my rig. Later next week my five Tremor road wheels wrapped in factory rubber will be stacked on a pallet and covered behind my garage, where that great wheel will wait for any decent 37 X 11.5 X 18.

CJC Offroad just posted a new Tremor project truck on which they started w/ their Commuter package and where they put 37 X 12.5 X 18 Toyo R/T Trails on the factory Tremor aluminum road wheel.

Dampers? Always a first order o' bidness deal. A gear-type limited slip (Eaton Truetrac, TorSen or Quaife) would work for me but a neat little locker to fit the new M235/9.25" ring gear carrier would the shnizz.

The running boards! The longer vent tubes! The "skid plates" for transfer case and fuel tank! Trail Turn Assist! drive mode... all great features contained in the Tremor Package. I'm happy to have those.

[not telling anyone anything they don't already know. I'm just riffing on the preceding post!]
 
Back
Top Bottom