7.3 Detonation at start up

I’ve recently done a bit of research because I always used to put expensive Shell Nitro V Power 93 in my trucks & cars. Here’s the bottom line, for the cases where your engine does NOT require higher octane due to compression ratios (such as most engines, except high performance ones):
- 87 octane in most cases actually yields BETTER power delivery than 93 octane. The reason being that people confuse octane with some kind of energy value of fuel, whereas it is really just the ability of the fuel to withstand pinging (speak premature detonation due to compression). Therefore, lower octane ignites “easier” at lower compression under normal conditions. Note that this relationship changes under heavy loads, actually causing 93 octane to yield a better performance under loads such as towing.
- This leaves you with the argument that 93 octane fuels or the VPowers of this world ensure better engine longevity due to the increased volume of detergents in the fuel. While this is certainly true and proven, it has very little to do with the octane level. It is purely a detergent question, which, as per common research, suggests that 87 octane fuel from top tier providers has “just enough detergents” to keep your engine clean and you don’t need the added ones from Shell VPower et cetera.
- The last argument for using higher octane fuel is mpg and this is highly dependent on the engine and can be quite different from type to type. However, Ford V8 engines haven proven to run more efficient on higher octanes than other manufacturers V8s. This difference is however negligible as we are speaking a maximum better result of 0.3-0.6 mpg more. Making the math with top tier fuels of 87 octane and 93 octane, this makes no sense from an economic perspective.

So, clearly, 93 octane and the VPowers of this world are a major consumer ripoff. Continue putting good gas in your truck, from a well known brand, but don’t bother with 93. 87 is just fine.

lastly, now come the fancy folks with the blanket statement of “You pay 80k on a truck, why bother saving 8$ on a full tank of gas, sacrificing longevity. As stated above, the longevity argument is invalid, and so are the performance ones outside of high load applications. So technically, this isn’t about money for me. I just don’t like being fooled by the system and buy into unsubstantiated beliefs. I feel better running 87 knowing it’s the intelligent choice versus running 93 for the sole benefit of the Oil & Gas shareholders.

I really enjoy these discussions, the 7.3 has a compression of 10.5:1. Most research would tell you to run higher octane in anything over 10:1 compression. Now, everyone says to read the owners manual. BUT I can ensure you if FORD stated “ run higher octane fuel in the high compression 7.3l it would deter many commercial buyers to steer clear of the 7.3l platform due to higher fuel costs and bulk fuel purchasing. (Ford is going to look after its best interest). Sure the 7.3l will run fine on 87 octane, ping sensors can detect pre detonation and retard the timing causing a loss of power and fuel economy (probably not enough to notice) but I would rather the engine computer not have to retard my timing due to pre-detonation. I will continue to run higher octane due to the above reasons, but that’s just me.
 
This has sparked (no pun intended) some very interesting view points. I'm not sure any of them are wrong, just more or less - the glass is half empty or half full.
 
Yo, good call. I have to change that to my Prius !
I honestly call the tremor my Prius as it gets the best mpg in my fleet ... Even the 2018 ford edge gets 29 at best but around here it is 21 ... Tremor gets 22 to 23 ... And with the 300 lbs bumper on the front
 
I really enjoy these discussions, the 7.3 has a compression of 10.5:1. Most research would tell you to run higher octane in anything over 10:1 compression. Now, everyone says to read the owners manual. BUT I can ensure you if FORD stated “ run higher octane fuel in the high compression 7.3l it would deter many commercial buyers to steer clear of the 7.3l platform due to higher fuel costs and bulk fuel purchasing. (Ford is going to look after its best interest). Sure the 7.3l will run fine on 87 octane, ping sensors can detect pre detonation and retard the timing causing a loss of power and fuel economy (probably not enough to notice) but I would rather the engine computer not have to retard my timing due to pre-detonation. I will continue to run higher octane due to the above reasons, but that’s just me.
So your argument is that the 7.3l is in fact a high compression engine benefiting more from the 93 octane than the “average” case I described above. That could very well be true, I have yet to see the comparison I made based on different compression ratios, but I did caveat that what I’m saying only holds true for the non-performance engines (which with its high compression ratio that 7.3l may not be dubbed as).
If that were the case, then Ford is suggesting in the owners manual to sacrifice power & mpg for the benefit of their sales, which generally seems like something Ford wouldn’t think twice about to do. In which case I’d be convinced again to grab that 93 octane handle. All that being said: I’ve run one tank of 87 octane thus far and at least 5 of 93.
 
Last edited:
I’ve recently done a bit of research because I always used to put expensive Shell Nitro V Power 93 in my trucks & cars. Here’s the bottom line, for the cases where your engine does NOT require higher octane due to compression ratios (such as most engines, except high performance ones):
- 87 octane in most cases actually yields BETTER power delivery than 93 octane. The reason being that people confuse octane with some kind of energy value of fuel, whereas it is really just the ability of the fuel to withstand pinging (speak premature detonation due to compression). Therefore, lower octane ignites “easier” at lower compression under normal conditions. Note that this relationship changes under heavy loads, actually causing 93 octane to yield a better performance under loads such as towing.
- This leaves you with the argument that 93 octane fuels or the VPowers of this world ensure better engine longevity due to the increased volume of detergents in the fuel. While this is certainly true and proven, it has very little to do with the octane level. It is purely a detergent question, which, as per common research, suggests that 87 octane fuel from top tier providers has “just enough detergents” to keep your engine clean and you don’t need the added ones from Shell VPower et cetera.
- The last argument for using higher octane fuel is mpg and this is highly dependent on the engine and can be quite different from type to type. However, Ford V8 engines haven proven to run more efficient on higher octanes than other manufacturers V8s. This difference is however negligible as we are speaking a maximum better result of 0.3-0.6 mpg more. Making the math with top tier fuels of 87 octane and 93 octane, this makes no sense from an economic perspective.

So, clearly, 93 octane and the VPowers of this world are a major consumer ripoff. Continue putting good gas in your truck, from a well known brand, but don’t bother with 93. 87 is just fine.

lastly, now come the fancy folks with the blanket statement of “You pay 80k on a truck, why bother saving 8$ on a full tank of gas, sacrificing longevity. As stated above, the longevity argument is invalid, and so are the performance ones outside of high load applications. So technically, this isn’t about money for me. I just don’t like being fooled by the system and buy into unsubstantiated beliefs. I feel better running 87 knowing it’s the intelligent choice versus running 93 for the sole benefit of the Oil & Gas shareholders.
@Trämör gets it! you really dont need 93 octane. Do your truck a favor and run 87. that being said lets get back to the Ops original issue, Detonation on startup. This may not be a fuel problem. I recommend getting it checked out at the dealer it may be a software issue with timing and or fuel mixture.
 
Not trying to debate octane rating, but the manual recommends using a minimum octane rating of 87. However it does state that for best overall vehicle and engine performance premium fuel with a rating of 91 or higher is recommended. So 87 or 91, I guess y’all are both right. I usually go for the highest octane available and that’s just me, not saying it’s right or wrong just what I do. What I do look for are top tier stations though, Ford also recommends this too. Usually there is a sticker on the pump that says top tier fuel or you can look up what stations or brands qualify as top tier.
Back to the OP I would definitely go to the dealer to have it check being a relatively new truck just to be safe.
 
Last edited:
The truck had been warmed up already and I shut it down for a second, started it back up to close my window and heard it. Proceeded to shut down and start it back up a couple times and heard it each time. Once running it went away. I hooked my boat up and towed it without hearing it as well. I am still using the same tank of fuel and just went out to driveway to start it cold and no detonation sound. Really odd. Maybe it was where I was parked and it just resonated off the glass store fronts? I dunno, I am pretty familiar with the sound of detonation since I grew up in the 70's when Dads woody station wagon would stay running after the key was turned off for 10 minutes lol .
The 7.3s have been known to come with a bad plug wire or 2 from the factory.......there is a TSB on it.
 
I will repeat myself again if you missed it: The 7.3s had a batch of bad plug wires....and there is a TSB on it I believe.......
 
Just jumped in the truck this morning to go grab a coffee. Same tank of gas since I first noticed it on Thursday. Started cold with no pre detonation. Drove up the block and back. Fired it back up in the driveway a few times after it was up to temp and definately heard it 3 of the 4 times I started it. Half second of clacking.

I'm gonna run another tank of 87 from BP and see if the problem goes away. If not I'll bring it to dealer.
 
87 Octane for me, only the Focus ST gets the premium...Too pricey to fill the Tremor's tank with 93 octane.
 
Not trying to debate octane rating, but the manual recommends using a minimum octane rating of 87. However it does state that for best overall vehicle and engine performance premium fuel with a rating of 91 or higher is recommended. So 87 or 91, I guess y’all are both right. I usually go for the highest octane available and that’s just me, not saying it’s right or wrong just what I do. What I do look for are top tier stations though, Ford also recommends this too. Usually there is a sticker on the pump that says top tier fuel or you can look up what stations or brands qualify as top tier.
Back to the OP I would definitely go to the dealer to have it check being a relatively new truck just to be safe.
That is very interesting - guess I will have to read my manual. If the engine can take advantage of higher Octane rated fuels I would be inclined to use them at least from time to time. But I agree that they are generally a waste of $ if the engine is not tuned for them.
 
If you're going to run 93 then you should consider adding the 5-Star 93 tune and get an extra ~25hp!
 
I’ve recently done a bit of research because I always used to put expensive Shell Nitro V Power 93 in my trucks & cars. Here’s the bottom line, for the cases where your engine does NOT require higher octane due to compression ratios (such as most engines, except high performance ones):
- 87 octane in most cases actually yields BETTER power delivery than 93 octane. The reason being that people confuse octane with some kind of energy value of fuel, whereas it is really just the ability of the fuel to withstand pinging (speak premature detonation due to compression). Therefore, lower octane ignites “easier” at lower compression under normal conditions. Note that this relationship changes under heavy loads, actually causing 93 octane to yield a better performance under loads such as towing.
- This leaves you with the argument that 93 octane fuels or the VPowers of this world ensure better engine longevity due to the increased volume of detergents in the fuel. While this is certainly true and proven, it has very little to do with the octane level. It is purely a detergent question, which, as per common research, suggests that 87 octane fuel from top tier providers has “just enough detergents” to keep your engine clean and you don’t need the added ones from Shell VPower et cetera.
- The last argument for using higher octane fuel is mpg and this is highly dependent on the engine and can be quite different from type to type. However, Ford V8 engines haven proven to run more efficient on higher octanes than other manufacturers V8s. This difference is however negligible as we are speaking a maximum better result of 0.3-0.6 mpg more. Making the math with top tier fuels of 87 octane and 93 octane, this makes no sense from an economic perspective.

So, clearly, 93 octane and the VPowers of this world are a major consumer ripoff. Continue putting good gas in your truck, from a well known brand, but don’t bother with 93. 87 is just fine.

lastly, now come the fancy folks with the blanket statement of “You pay 80k on a truck, why bother saving 8$ on a full tank of gas, sacrificing longevity. As stated above, the longevity argument is invalid, and so are the performance ones outside of high load applications. So technically, this isn’t about money for me. I just don’t like being fooled by the system and buy into unsubstantiated beliefs. I feel better running 87 knowing it’s the intelligent choice versus running 93 for the sole benefit of the Oil & Gas shareholders.
Great explanation! Thank you!
 
No tanker present at last fill up. I am chalking this up to bad gas though, since it has 4000 miles and it's always run fine on 87. I'll monitor, and if I hear it again bring it to the dealer.
I agree with you sounds like bad fuel. the engine computer should be able to adjust the timing for the octanes.
I would run the 87 and once and while put some premium in it. ( just like an E-85 vehicle , run a few tanks then flush it out with 93.)
 
I’ve recently done a bit of research because I always used to put expensive Shell Nitro V Power 93 in my trucks & cars. Here’s the bottom line, for the cases where your engine does NOT require higher octane due to compression ratios (such as most engines, except high performance ones):
- 87 octane in most cases actually yields BETTER power delivery than 93 octane. The reason being that people confuse octane with some kind of energy value of fuel, whereas it is really just the ability of the fuel to withstand pinging (speak premature detonation due to compression). Therefore, lower octane ignites “easier” at lower compression under normal conditions. Note that this relationship changes under heavy loads, actually causing 93 octane to yield a better performance under loads such as towing.
- This leaves you with the argument that 93 octane fuels or the VPowers of this world ensure better engine longevity due to the increased volume of detergents in the fuel. While this is certainly true and proven, it has very little to do with the octane level. It is purely a detergent question, which, as per common research, suggests that 87 octane fuel from top tier providers has “just enough detergents” to keep your engine clean and you don’t need the added ones from Shell VPower et cetera.
- The last argument for using higher octane fuel is mpg and this is highly dependent on the engine and can be quite different from type to type. However, Ford V8 engines haven proven to run more efficient on higher octanes than other manufacturers V8s. This difference is however negligible as we are speaking a maximum better result of 0.3-0.6 mpg more. Making the math with top tier fuels of 87 octane and 93 octane, this makes no sense from an economic perspective.

So, clearly, 93 octane and the VPowers of this world are a major consumer ripoff. Continue putting good gas in your truck, from a well known brand, but don’t bother with 93. 87 is just fine.

lastly, now come the fancy folks with the blanket statement of “You pay 80k on a truck, why bother saving 8$ on a full tank of gas, sacrificing longevity. As stated above, the longevity argument is invalid, and so are the performance ones outside of high load applications. So technically, this isn’t about money for me. I just don’t like being fooled by the system and buy into unsubstantiated beliefs. I feel better running 87 knowing it’s the intelligent choice versus running 93 for the sole benefit of the Oil & Gas shareholders.
I agree but he got a bad batch of fuel or it was contaminated
 
I still contend that detonation on startup is very odd / rare and should be diagnosed at the dealer. Prevent rather than repair later. Enough guessing by all of us.
 
I must say, I always appreciate all the advice here. This time, I'm a little sorry I asked. You guys be like...

Don't run 89
Run 93
No Don't run 93
Mix it
87 is fine
I run 93
87 in the cold?

It's like I just asked my wife and daughters what they want for dinner! :rolleyes:
Let me add to the confusion. I live at 5200 ft and they sell 85 octane here for regular. I run it all the time with no issues. Mostly Sinclair.
 
Back
Top Bottom